HomeHealthIs bone density really about diet? Dr Gregers' answer may surprise you

Is bone density really about diet? Dr Gregers’ answer may surprise you

by Peter Barclay

Do people who eat plant-based diets have weaker bones? It seems like a reasonable concern and one that has lingered in nutrition circles for several years. After all, vegetarians and vegans consume less dairy and fewer animal products, foods long promoted as essential for bone health.

But the latest evidence, as reviewed by Dr Michael Greger and presented in his video below, suggests that we may have been asking the wrong question all along. The issue may not be what plant-based eaters are consuming. It may be how much they weigh.

Osteoporosis affects an estimated 200 million people worldwide. The disease is characterised by weakened bones caused by excessive bone loss, inadequate bone formation, or both. Because lower bone mineral density (BMD) strongly predicts fracture risk, researchers have spent decades searching for dietary patterns that help preserve skeletal strength.

The story initially appeared promising for plant foods. Research has consistently shown that greater consumption of fruits, vegetables, legumes, and other whole plant foods is associated with higher bone mineral density. Plants deliver a rich package of vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, and phytochemicals that appear to support bone health throughout life.

At the same time, dietary patterns centred on animal-derived foods have been associated with increased fracture risk and greater bone fragility. Based on these observations, one might expect vegetarians and vegans to enjoy superior bone health.

Scientific plot twist

The first major study comparing vegetarians and meat eaters was published nearly fifty years ago. Researchers concluded that vegetarians had denser bones and were less likely to develop osteoporosis as they aged. In fact, the vegetarian participants in their seventies appeared to have better bone density than meat eaters in their fifties.

But science has a way of correcting itself.

The problem was the technology. Modern DEXA scans, considered the gold standard for measuring bone density, did not yet exist. Researchers relied on conventional X-rays and misunderstood how to interpret the images. Darker images, which actually indicated lower bone mass, were mistakenly scored as healthier bones. The original conclusion was effectively reversed. The vegetarians had lower measured bone density, not higher.

Delving deeper

Fast forward four decades and the scientific literature became much larger. Multiple studies involving thousands of participants were analysed together. The overall finding was consistent: vegetarians, and especially vegans, tended to have slightly lower bone mineral density than meat eaters.

But there was an important caveat.

The differences were so small that researchers considered them clinically insignificant. In other words, while statistical differences existed, they were not large enough to meaningfully affect real-world bone health outcomes. These findings reinforced the conclusion that vegetarian diets do not appear to harm bone health.

Still, Dr Greger points to a critical oversight that many studies failed to address.

The missing piece

People who follow whole-food, plant-based diets are generally leaner than the average population. They also have dramatically lower rates of obesity.

This matters because body weight itself influences bone density.

Heavier individuals place more mechanical stress on their skeletons every day. Carrying extra weight essentially acts like a constant form of weight-bearing exercise, prompting bones to become denser and stronger. Conversely, slimmer individuals often have lower bone density simply because their bones are exposed to less daily loading.

Many earlier studies comparing vegetarians and omnivores failed to adequately account for these differences in body size. As a result, some researchers may have mistakenly attributed lower bone density to diet when it was actually related to body weight.

A changed conversation

The turning point, according to Dr Greger, came in 2020, when researchers revisited the evidence with a more sophisticated approach.

Their study examined whether the differences in bone mineral density between vegetarians and nonvegetarians remained after adjusting for factors such as body mass index (BMI) and waist circumference.

Initially, vegetarians still appeared to have lower bone density. But once body size was taken into account, most of those differences disappeared. In fact, many lost statistical significance altogether. The researchers concluded that the lower bone mineral density observed in vegetarian populations was largely explained by their smaller body size rather than by the composition of their diets.

A tiny difference remained in spinal bone density, but even that fell below the threshold considered clinically meaningful in routine medical practice. The variation was so small that it could not be distinguished from normal measurement variability.

Australia and New Zealand

Worldwide: ~200 million women are affected by osteoporosis.

Global lifetime risk after age 50: 1 in 3 women, 1 in 5 men.

Australia: 652,500 diagnosed cases (age 50+) in 2011-12.

New Zealand: 70,000+ diagnosed cases (age 50+) in 2007, likely an underestimate.

Australia & New Zealand: Both rank among countries with substantial osteoporosis and fracture burdens due to ageing populations.

A critical conclusion

Dr Greger’s review leads to an important conclusion: the common assumption that plant-based diets inherently weaken bones is not supported when body size is properly considered.

The more relevant concern is not whether someone eats plants or animal products, but whether they fall into a low-body-weight category. Regardless of dietary preference, people with very low BMI may face a higher risk of fractures and osteoporosis and should be monitored accordingly.

For advocates of whole-food, plant-based living, this is encouraging news. The nutrients naturally packaged within vegetables, fruits, legumes, whole grains, nuts, and seeds continue to offer broad health benefits, including support for bone health. The emerging evidence suggests that a thoughtfully planned plant-based diet does not compromise bone strength simply because it excludes animal products.

Finally, I think the real value of Dr Greger’s latest review is that nutrition science rarely stands still. What began as a concern about vegetarian diets and fragile bones evolved into a deeper understanding of the powerful role body size plays in skeletal health. Sometimes the answer isn’t hiding on our plate. Sometimes it lies in factors researchers overlooked.

In this case, the evidence suggests that the slimmer waistlines often achieved through whole-food, plant-based eating may explain far more about bone density than the absence of meat or dairy ever did.

Peter Barclay
Peter Barclayhttp://www.wholefoodliving.life
Has a professional background in journalism, photography and design. He is a passionate Kiwi traveler and an ardent evangelist for protecting all the good things New Zealand is best known for. With his wife Catherine is also the co-owner of Wholefoodliving.
RELATED ARTICLES

Sign up to our newsletter

For the latest in news, recipes and alerts be sure to sign up to our newsletter to stay up to date.

Most Popular